SOUTH AFRICA – For the first time, South Africa has escalated a trade dispute to the panel level at the World Trade Organization (WTO).

This week, South Africa requested the formation of two panels to address unfair measures imposed by the European Union (EU) on its citrus exports.

South Africa’s move seeks to challenge the EU’s regulations on citrus imports, specifically targeting the Citrus Black Spot (CBS) and False Codling Moth (FCM) plant health measures.

These regulations, South Africa argues, are unscientific and discriminatory. The South African government aims to safeguard the livelihoods of tens of thousands of workers in the citrus industry, who bear significant costs to comply with these stringent measures.

“The current regulations are unnecessarily restrictive and place a heavy burden on our citrus growers,” stated a spokesperson from the South African Department of Trade and Industry.

“We are hopeful that the establishment of these panels will lead to a fair and scientifically accurate resolution.”

The WTO Process

The WTO’s dispute settlement mechanism involves several stages, beginning with consultations. Countries in dispute must first attempt to resolve their issues through dialogue within 60 days.

If this fails, the complaining country can request the formation of a panel. This panel, once established, has six months to present its findings, although the process can be expedited in urgent cases involving perishable goods.

The panel’s role is to assist the Dispute Settlement Body (DSB) in making rulings or recommendations. The panel’s findings are challenging to overturn, as they require a consensus from the DSB to be rejected. This ensures that the panel’s conclusions carry significant weight in resolving the dispute.

Implications for the Citrus Industry

South Africa’s citrus industry is a vital part of its economy, with thousands of jobs depending on it. The dispute with the EU has highlighted the challenges faced by local growers.

Compliance with the CBS and FCM measures is costly and time-consuming. The industry hopes that the WTO panels will lead to a more equitable trading environment.

“The measures imposed by the EU are not only costly but also seem to lack scientific justification,” said Justin Chadwick, CEO of the Citrus Growers Association of Southern Africa. “We are optimistic that the WTO process will help rectify this situation.”

While the EU has not immediately accepted South Africa’s request, the panels are expected to be established by July 2024.

The WTO process aims to address these trade-related concerns through dialogue and adjudication rather than confrontation. Both parties will present their cases, and the panel will consult experts if needed.

The establishment of these panels marks a significant milestone in South Africa’s trade relations. It is the first time the country has advanced a dispute to this level at the WTO, reflecting the importance of the issue at hand.

“We are committed to ensuring that our citrus industry is treated fairly in the global market,” said the South African Minister of Trade and Industry. “This dispute is crucial for protecting the interests of our growers and ensuring sustainable trade practices.”

For all the latest fresh produce industry news updates from Africa, the Middle East, and the World, subscribe to our NEWSLETTER, follow us on Twitter and LinkedIn, like us on Facebook, and subscribe to our YouTube channel.